During his response to the Motion of Thanks in the Budget Session, Prime Minister Modi made several thought-provoking cultural allusions. One notable reference was to a famous cartoon by R.K. Laxman in The Times of India, which depicted the ever-present “common man” struggling to drag a float carrying an airplane filled with politicians, with the pilot bearing a striking resemblance to former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi. Modi also brought attention to JFK’s Forgotten Crisis: Tibet, the CIA, and the Sino-Indian War by Bruce Riedel, a former CIA officer and senior fellow at the Brookings Institution. This book offers an insightful analysis of the 1962 Sino-Indian War and its far-reaching implications on U.S. foreign policy during President John F. Kennedy’s administration.

What is in JFK’s Forgotten Crisis: Tibet, the CIA, and the Sino-Indian War?

The early 1960s marked a turbulent period in global geopolitics, defined by the Cold War rivalry between the United States and the Soviet Union, and the emergence of newly independent nations attempting to assert their sovereignty in an increasingly polarized world. India, led by its first Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru, was a key architect of the Non-Aligned Movement, advocating for a neutral position in the ongoing East-West conflict. Nehru’s vision was rooted in ideals of peaceful coexistence and diplomacy, and he hoped to maintain good relations with both superpowers. However, a series of unexpected developments, both within India’s borders and across its northern frontier, would soon challenge this idealism and force the nation to confront the harsh realities of international power politics.

The Sino-Indian Conflict: A Brief History

One of the most significant events in this period was the Sino-Indian War of 1962. As tensions escalated between India and China over contested border regions, particularly in Aksai Chin and Arunachal Pradesh, the world witnessed a dramatic shift in the balance of power in Asia. The war caught India off guard, as Nehru’s diplomatic approach had left the country ill-prepared for the scale of the military confrontation that unfolded in the Himalayan region. R.K. Laxman’s iconic cartoon in The Times of India famously depicted the common man struggling under the weight of a massive float carrying a group of politicians, with a pilot resembling former Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi. The image encapsulated the disconnect between India’s political leadership and the reality of its military unpreparedness during this critical time.

The Decline of “Hindi-Chini Bhai Bhai”

At the heart of this conflict lay India’s strained relationship with China, which had undergone significant changes following the Communist Revolution of 1949. China’s new leadership, under Chairman Mao Zedong, had increasingly adopted an assertive stance on its territorial disputes, particularly with India. While India had long maintained cordial relations with China, symbolized by the slogan “Hindi-Chini Bhai Bhai” (India and China are brothers), the growing territorial disagreements between the two countries became untenable, especially as China’s ambitions in Tibet and the disputed border regions took center stage. The Tibetan uprising in 1959, which led to India granting asylum to the Dalai Lama, further exacerbated Sino-Indian relations and set the stage for the confrontation that would unfold three years later.

The War Unfolds: India’s Strategic Miscalculations

The outbreak of the Sino-Indian War in October 1962 occurred against the backdrop of other significant global events, including the Cuban Missile Crisis, which brought the United States and the Soviet Union to the brink of nuclear war. While the Cuban crisis dominated the international spotlight, the Sino-Indian conflict was equally consequential for India’s internal politics and its role in global diplomacy. Bruce Riedel’s JFK’s Forgotten Crisis: Tibet, the CIA, and the Sino-Indian War offers a detailed account of the war’s impact on both India and global geopolitics, shedding light on the complexities of Nehru’s foreign policy and the strategic miscalculations that led to India’s military defeat.

Nehru’s Idealism vs. China’s Realpolitik

Riedel’s analysis emphasizes that while Nehru’s commitment to diplomacy and non-alignment was commendable, it also blinded him to the growing military threat posed by China. Intelligence reports had flagged Chinese aggression along India’s borders, but Nehru, convinced that diplomacy could still resolve the crisis, failed to adequately prepare the Indian military for an armed conflict. When the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) launched a swift and coordinated offensive in October 1962, India was caught off guard. Its forces were under-equipped, poorly trained for high-altitude warfare, and ill-prepared for the scale of the Chinese military’s aggression. The result was a crushing defeat for India, with Chinese forces making significant territorial gains before a unilateral ceasefire was declared.

The Aftermath: A Crisis of Confidence

The war had profound consequences for Nehru’s leadership and for India’s foreign and defense policies. The defeat exposed significant weaknesses in India’s defense infrastructure and shattered the idealistic worldview that Nehru had championed. Riedel notes that the war deeply affected Nehru’s morale, as he faced both domestic and international criticism for the country’s lack of preparedness. However, the crisis also marked a turning point for India’s foreign relations, particularly with the United States. In a desperate move, Nehru sought military assistance from President John F. Kennedy’s administration, marking a significant shift in India’s approach to the Cold War. Despite their ideological differences, Kennedy’s administration responded swiftly, providing military aid, including weapons, ammunition, and logistical support, to help India stabilize its defense capabilities.

Indo-US Cooperation: A New Chapter in Relations

This moment of cooperation between India and the United States is particularly notable given Nehru’s longstanding reluctance to align with either of the Cold War superpowers. Riedel suggests that Nehru’s appeal to the United States during the crisis laid the groundwork for a brief but meaningful period of Indo-US cooperation, centered around shared concerns over China’s rise as a regional power. The personal rapport that developed between Nehru and Kennedy during this time helped to bridge some of the ideological divides between their respective nations, even as the broader geopolitical landscape remained defined by competition and rivalry.

Reforms and Lessons Learned: India’s Strategic Shift

In the aftermath of the war, India undertook significant reforms to address its military deficiencies, including a major military build-up and a reassessment of its foreign policy priorities. Nehru, though deeply affected by the loss, oversaw these changes, recognizing that India could not afford to rely solely on diplomacy and moral authority in its dealings with more powerful neighbors. The experience of the 1962 war ultimately shaped India’s defense strategy for decades to come, and the lessons learned from that conflict continue to influence India’s approach to national security and foreign relations today.

Nehru’s Legacy: A Balancing Act Between Idealism and Pragmatism

While Riedel’s JFK’s Forgotten Crisis critiques Nehru’s missteps, it also underscores his ability to adapt in the face of adversity. The defeat in 1962 forced Nehru to confront the limitations of idealism in international relations, and the subsequent shift in India’s defense and foreign policy reflected a more pragmatic approach to securing the nation’s interests on the global stage. The war, while devastating in the short term, ultimately served as a catalyst for India’s modernization efforts and its evolving role in international geopolitics.

Read More: The Untold Truth About Trump’s China Strategy: Will It Lead to America’s Golden Age?