‘Another Simple Favor’: Sequel’s Shocking Scene Leaves Fans Disturbed

The much-anticipated thriller-comedy Another Simple Favor brings back Blake Lively and Anna Kendrick in a stylish but controversial sequel that has sparked intense debate online.

Dark Comedy Takes a Darker Turn

While fans expected more of the quirky suspense and sharp humor from the original A Simple Favor, the sequel delivered a controversial twist that caught viewers off guard. Blake Lively, reprising her role as Emily, now plays triplets—Emily, Faith, and Charity. However, a disturbing incestuous scene between the sisters, all portrayed by Lively, left many viewers uncomfortable.

Viewers React: “I Am Horrified”

Social media was quick to react. One X (formerly Twitter) user exclaimed,
“GUYSSSS I AM HORRIFIED. Why is Blake Lively’s twin making sexual advances to her? HEEELPP.”
Others echoed the sentiment, calling the moment “gross, weird, and unnecessary.”

Reddit Chimes In: Too Dark for a Comedy

Reddit discussions highlighted both praise and criticism. Some enjoyed Kendrick’s humor, but even fans admitted the incest scene was “too much.” One user said,
“The dynamic of two people who don’t like each other wasn’t fun to watch.”
Another called the scene “disturbing,” especially due to its implied assault elements.

Insensitive Themes in a ‘Frivolous’ Film?

While the film carries a tone of playful mystery, many felt it strayed too far into offensive territory. One viewer criticized its casual treatment of serious topics like incest, sexual assault, and abuse, stating:
“These shouldn’t be played for laughs or shock value.”

Plot Recap: Murder, Mystery & Capri Glam

According to the official synopsis, Stephanie Smothers (Kendrick) and Emily Nelson (Lively) reunite on Italy’s scenic Capri island for Emily’s lavish wedding. But things spiral quickly into murder and betrayal.

Blake Lively Reacts to the Controversial Twist

Speaking to Entertainment Weekly, Lively—who also starred in It Ends With Us—shared her thoughts on the surprising sibling storyline, saying:
“Okay, no nerves. I know what I’m doing this time.”
However, fans seem less convinced about that.

Final Verdict: One Scene Overshadows All

Despite the film’s glossy production and moments of wit, the incestuous subplot has become the main talking point. For many viewers, it was simply “too weird to handle.”